Two Important New Books on the Underground Railroad in New York City Complement One Another

Two recent books address the Underground Railroad saga, emphasizing its workings throughout the eastern United States especially concentrating on its operation in New York City. I highly recommend Eric Foner’s Gateway to Freedom: The Hidden History of the Underground Railroad (W. W. Norton & Company, 2015) and Don Papson and Tom Calarco’s Secret Lives of the Underground Railroad in New York City: Sydney Howard Gay, Louis Napoleon and the Record of Fugitives (McFarland, 2015). Each book represents an outstanding contribution to our understanding of this clandestine system….

The incredible detail, put down by Gay, of how this clandestine business worked in the mid-1850s is one of the most significant finds about the Underground Railroad ever uncovered. Included are the previously unknown efforts of black “agent” Louis Napoleon who worked as Gay’s right-hand man. In his book, Foner includes useful charts and maps and he skillfully weaves into his text Gay’s remarkably recorded revelations.

Don Papson and Tom Calarco are Underground Railroad researchers, each of whom is a past recipient of an Underground Railroad Free Press Prize. Their new book, like Foner’s, lays out the Underground Railroad story throughout the East. This work is organized as a documentary history and therein we find one of the major differences between the two books. Papson and Calarco meticulously present information that requires one to become familiar with numerous pieces of correspondence, sources, and accounts that are often quoted at length. They aptly use Sydney Howard Gay’s records and notes to show New York City’s connections to a wide-ranging network from eastern southern slave states into Pennsylvania, New York and New England. They discuss the overlapping relationship of black and white agents, but also present, as does Foner, a vivid account of the squabbling and infighting among various anti-slavery groups, particularly the loathing that existed between William L. Garrison’s Boston abolitionist band and Lewis Tappan’s New York City cohorts. (Both books disclose, however, that these differences were put aside when it was required to aid escaping slaves.)

This book’s description of Gay’s relationship with Louis Napoleon is often quite moving and leaves no doubt about the central role this black agent played ushering fugitives out of the city towards safe ty. The authors illuminate the crucial part played by a number of militant black abolitionists and “station masters” like David Ruggles, Samuel Ringgold Ward, Henry Highland Garnet, Jermain W. Loguen and others, including the better known Harriet Tubman and Frederick Douglass.

An outstanding appendix gives the reader the opportunity to read in chronological order when, where, how, and to whom fugitives were sent. In some instances, this chart was put together by using New York City newspapers to pinpoint the arrival of ships captained by men who had a history of transporting escapees and matching this information with Gay’s notations. Any student of the Underground Railroad will welcome the opportunity to pour over this appendix

The most telling message that emerges from both books is the reminder that fugitivevslaves demonstrated incredible courage when they fle…each book is a blockbuster and should be added to the library bookshelves of important publications about the Underground Railroad story

Owen Muelder, Director of the Galesburg Colony Underground Railroad Freedom Center at Knox College, from the Underground Railroad Free Press, March 2015. Vol. 10, number 53



 


Comments

06/01/2015 11:28am

The railroads in New York City are amazing! I can't imagine how hard those people worked in order to create the Underground Railroad. Thanks for post!

Reply

I like to read about the life of the well known people, as I can take a lot of interesting facts from the writer of the post to make some changes in my life.

Reply
07/11/2015 3:07am

An extremely useful web-site. How you may have share this info is actually incredibly appreciative. Hope to view much more on this matter below. Thanks for publishing this data in this article.

Reply
07/11/2015 3:08am

An extremely useful web-site. How you may have share this info is actually incredibly appreciative. Hope to view much more on this matter below. Thanks for publishing this data in this article.

Reply
08/01/2015 12:05pm

I must give you two thumbs up for this great reading. I may have to come up here in the upcoming days to see whether there's new article or not. Keep blogging!

Reply
08/12/2015 2:00pm

Like it, should be admitted that it's absolutely inspiring article!

Reply
08/18/2015 1:41pm

Never thought such issue before, yet now I knew it well. Thanks for the author.

Reply
08/19/2015 8:18am

The review was an awesome and great job done by Owen Muelder.

Reply
08/23/2015 5:11am

It is a very interesting and informative story. Just by its title, it has already caught the attention of your visitors. The best thing I liked about your post is that you do not need to write fancy things just to draw in readers. I appreciate your effort in sharing these literary pieces. I enjoyed visiting your web page. I will check on this page more often.

Reply
08/27/2015 7:34pm

Wow, it's a very deep analysis. Thank you!

Reply
09/24/2015 8:24am

This is a great webpage to give information to more & more

Reply
10/01/2015 3:54pm

Dear Don and Tom, My husband, John George Gay, and I both read your book about Sydney Howard Gay and absolutely loved it! You did a superb job - of course! So fascinating! Personally, I loved the linkages to many of the suffragettes I wrote about in my 2009 book, Strength Without Compromise. My husband was very grateful for the thorough biography of his ancestor; Sydney Howard Gay is the son of John's great- great- great - grandfather Ebenezer Gay. And, would you believe: in 9th grade (in Glens Falls, NY), I was in a select singing group,called "13th Day," led by a woman named Constance Zweifel who was from Scituate, MA, and our little group took a trip to Scituate and Hingham in 1974 for a concert tour. We sang in the old Ship Church and stayed with families who were members of the church (as Mrs. Zweifel's parents were). I still have my photographs from that trip -- 42 years ago! -- including pictures of the Old Ship Church. It's quite a coincidence that I grew up to marry a man whose ancestor founded that church! Kudos to your both on this outstanding book! -- Teri Podnorszki Gay

Reply
10/13/2015 4:18pm

Very strong and insightful review. It is a very interesting and informative story. Just by its title, it has already caught the attention of your visitors.

Reply
10/13/2015 4:20pm

Good review. read your book about Sydney Howard Gay and absolutely loved it! You did a superb job - of course! So fascinating! Personally, I loved the linkages to many of the suffragettes I wrote about in my 2009 book, Strength Without Compromise.

Reply
10/13/2015 4:22pm

Amazing and pithy. I was very grateful for the thorough biography of his ancestor; Sydney Howard Gay is the son of John's great- great- great - grandfather Ebenezer Gay. And, would you believe: in 9th grade (in Glens Falls, NY), I was in a select singing group,called "13th Day," led by a woman named Constance Zweifel who was from Scituate, MA, and our little group took a trip to Scituate and Hingham in 1974 for a concert tour. We sang in the old Ship Church and stayed with families who were members of the church (as Mrs. Zweifel's parents were).

Reply
10/16/2015 11:18am

I dont need this dirty laundry!

Reply
10/26/2015 9:45pm

Well, thank you for making such useful article.

Reply
11/15/2015 7:14pm

Sometimes we need to know this case immediately. Thank, you've made it clearer for us.

Reply
11/24/2015 10:55am

Many web use this article for references and I think, they're right. It's so informative.

Reply
11/27/2015 10:58am

Many people have written such kind of idea, yet you've made simpler and better. 2 thumbs up.

Reply
12/04/2015 2:16am

Chemistry Assignment Help and Online Homework Help includes the study of matter as well as their changes. Matter is the mix of pure parts.

Reply
12/04/2015 2:34am

Our website is number 1 in Auditing Assignment Help and Auditing Homework Help. This is preferred destination for various students to get their Audit Projects and Homework Done.

Reply

Code Access Security C# Assignment Help, Online C# Homework & Project Help What is the importance of code access security? With role-based security, you can define what the user is allowed to do.

Reply
12/04/2015 6:13am

Physics Homework Help is available for Physics Projects and Homework and assignments.

Reply
12/04/2015 6:31am

SPSS Stats Homework, assignment and Project Help, SPSS Assignment Help It is a statistical software that is used in the discipline of statistics in order to evaluate the data or statistics.

Reply
12/19/2015 5:24am

Thanks to tell us about this information about New York City underground Railways.i am really happy to be here.

Reply

It's great you have update it.thank you.I discovered this is an interesting and also fascinating post.

Reply
03/18/2016 1:45am

It is really difficult to find such a fantastic content with some useful information.

Reply
03/31/2016 3:22pm

I like your lovely post.

Reply
04/10/2016 7:56pm

I must say that this article is very useful for us. Thank You!

Reply
04/17/2016 2:05am

This was a really great contest and hopefully I can attend the next one.

Reply
05/08/2016 10:58am

Very awesome post you share with us i would like to say that you both are looking perfect.

Reply
06/13/2016 11:47am

I appreciate all the ongoing work you placed into this site,

Reply
06/13/2016 2:15pm

Sometimes we need to know this issue more than what we heard. Thank you.

Reply
06/23/2016 2:11pm

it's very interesting post .

Reply

A very deep analysis! We really understand this issue right now.

Reply
09/03/2016 10:16am

Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can't wait to read lots of your posts

Reply
10/04/2016 12:01am

Thanks for sharing here.
I am very happy to read your review.

Reply
10/21/2016 3:47am

I read the blog and I must say this is the best article for the learning about the new things. You are just awesome.

Reply
10/31/2016 11:12pm

I think you guys did a huge job! I am sure you got a lot of congratulations of this work! You look happy and satisfied on picture in blog. I hope it was a good experience for both of you. Some writing help can be useful.

Reply
11/17/2016 10:07pm

This article has fully imprecise my brain. Truthfully I have never learn like this type of place but first time focus here. Really exciting article has been shared

Reply
12/25/2016 1:50pm

So you got a lodging credit as well, and you are arranging a prepayment for it. Presently would it be advisable for you to? Choose which of your advance is great or awful. Choose which credit has the most pressurizing impact on you.

Reply
12/25/2016 11:12pm

The reigns and holding my family up. So technically, this was one of my first thoughts at the dinner table that night.

Reply

Reply
06/11/2017 11:49am

Interesting i like that

Reply
07/07/2017 6:41am

There are some interesting points in time in this article but I don’t know if I see all of them center to heart. There is some validity but I will take hold opinion until I look into it further

Reply



Leave a Reply